• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • The words
  • The writer
  • The work

Beauty on the Backroads

Stories of grace for life's unexpected turns

classic literature

When letters tell the story: Review of Dear Mr. Knightley by Katherine Reay

January 1, 2014

A new  year upon us means a new year of reading and books, and I’m thrilled to start 2014 with a review of a book I wasn’t sure I would like when I started it.

knightleyKatherine Reay’s debut novel Dear Mr. Knightley drew me in with its Jane Austen reference in the title. (Disclaimer: I received a free copy of the book in exchange for my review through the Booksneeze program.) What I didn’t realize is that it’s written entirely in letters. The main character, Samantha Moore, is an orphan looking for meaning in her life. Thanks to a mysterious benefecator, she applies to the presitgious Medill School of Journalism at Northwestern University and is accepted. The condition of her endowment is that she write letters regularly to the benefactor, who has taken the name Mr. Knightley.

So, the story unfolds in Sam’s letters to this man, which end up reading somewhat like a journal because Mr. Knightley seldom writes back. It’s not meant to be a correspondance. And, admittedly, it takes some getting used to. But as an introvert and a writer, I came to appreciate the novel’s style. And the story is compelling as we wonder if she’ll make it through the rigorous journalism program and if she’ll ever discover who Mr. Knightley is.

It’s fun and different, and because Sam has such a love for classic literature, I found myself making a mental list of books I want to read or re-read. The characters in these classic novels are her friends and part of her identity, and I felt like I knew them better because of her attachment to them.

So, reading this book has given me a dozen others to add to my reading list for the new year.

If you’re a fan of Austen, I think you’ll like this one, especially if you’re familiar enough with her works to get all the references to characters and quotes from her books.

Filed Under: Fiction, The Weekly Read Tagged With: classic literature, dear mr. knightley, debut novels, jane austen, katherine reay, medill school of journalism

Primary Sidebar

Photo by Rachel Lynn Photography

Welcome

Hi. I’m Lisa, and I’m glad you’re here. If we were meeting in real life, I’d offer you something to eat or drink while we sat on the porch letting the conversation wander as it does. That’s a little bit what this space is like. We talk about books and family and travel and food and running, whatever I might encounter in world. I’m looking for the beauty in the midst of it all, even the tough stuff. (You’ll find a lot of that here, too.) Thanks for stopping by. Stay as long as you like.

When I wrote something

June 2025
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  
« Jun    

Recent posts

  • Still Life
  • A final round-up for 2022: What our December was like
  • Endings and beginnings … plus soup: A November wrap-up
  • A magical month of ordinary days: October round-up
  • Stuck in a shallow creek
  • Short and sweet September: a monthly round-up
  • Wrapping the end of summer: Our monthly round-up

Join the conversation

  • A magical month of ordinary days: October round-up on Stuck in a shallow creek
  • Stuck in a shallow creek on This is 40
  • July was all about vacation (and getting back to ordinary days after)–a monthly roundup on One very long week

Footer

What I write about

Looking for something?

Disclosure

Lisa Bartelt is a participant in the Bluehost Affiliate Program.

Occasionally, I review books in exchange for a free copy. Opinions are my own and are not guaranteed positive simply due to the receipt of a free copy.

Copyright © 2025 · Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in